Fumbled Pass or Touchdown?
The Future of Super Bowl Marketing in a Digital Age
The Super Bowl. Glittering, star-studded, and undeniably expensive. In the advertising world, it's a holy grail, a 30-second portal to brand heaven. But in 2024, is it still worth worshipping? Or is it time to question the value behind the sky-high price tag and captive audience?
Let's dissect the behemoth:
The Cost of Fame: A 30-second Super Bowl ad cost an average of $7 million in 2023. That's enough to fuel a small rocket program (or a very fancy party). Companies justify it by shouting at 100 million viewers, captive during the big game and halftime extravaganza. Sounds like a guaranteed win, right?
Hold your horses. While reach is undeniable, engagement isn't guaranteed. Those millions pay for fleeting attention, battling against a barrage of flashy competitors all vying for the same eyeballs. Factor in forgetfulness (studies show half the ads are gone by the next day), and suddenly the ROI starts to look hazy.
Beyond the Buzz: Sure, a funny ad might generate social media buzz and a temporary brand lift. But does it translate to sales? The jury's still out. Some brands see a bump, others? Crickets. And with digital marketing offering precise targeting and measurable results, the one-size-fits-all Super Bowl approach seems… antique.
So, fluff or hope? It's complicated. For established giants with deep pockets and brand awareness goals, the Super Bowl can be a strategic (and ego-boosting) play. But for smaller players, it's a risky gamble.
Here's the real challenge:
Shifting focus: Instead of chasing fleeting virality, invest in targeted, personalized digital campaigns that build lasting relationships with customers.
Content is king: Ditch the predictable slapstick and create ads that genuinely resonate with audiences, offering value beyond the spectacle.
Measure everything: Don't just chase eyeballs, track engagement, conversions, and ROI to quantify the real impact of your ad spend.
The Super Bowl might still be a marketing behemoth, but its reign isn't absolute. By questioning its value and exploring alternative strategies, brands can find more cost-effective and impactful ways to reach their audiences and achieve their marketing goals.
Personal experience insight
In 2021, I was tasked to produce our Big Game ad. The goal was not to get conversions, but to be “part of these brands that did it”. There was a 360 strategy in place, integrated with our Q1 OOH campaign, as well as a PR effort. All this eventually translated as:
brand awareness amplifier;
built trust (if they can be on prime-time TV, they probably are good at what they do);
put us on the map.
With the increase of data privacy regulation on one end and the appetite from companies for more trackability and conversion, the relevance of Superbowl ads, beyond sheer industry recognition and PR is threatened.
What do you think? Is the Super Bowl still a marketing must-have or a relic of the past? Share your thoughts in the comments!
P.S. This blog post itself wouldn't cost $7 million, but it might spark some interesting conversations.
Thanks for reading!
Connect with me on LinkedIn
Please drop a comment below, let me know your take 👇, and subscribe here.
Listen🎙️ to the Brand Runner podcast on: